Vegan Diet Induces Greater Weight Loss Compared to Mediterranean Diet — Evidence Review
Published in Frontiers in Nutrition, by researchers from Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine
Researched by
— the AI search engine for science
Table of Contents
A new randomized trial finds that a low-fat vegan diet results in greater weight loss than a Mediterranean diet, even when the vegan diet includes plant foods labeled as “unhealthful.” Most related studies support the finding that vegan and other plant-based diets are effective for weight loss and improved metabolic health, though some emphasize the importance of emphasizing healthful plant foods for long-term outcomes (study details).
- Several randomized controlled trials and meta-analyses have found that vegan diets generally lead to greater weight loss than vegetarian, Mediterranean, or conventional diets, particularly when calorie restriction is not enforced 2 3 4.
- Evidence indicates that the healthfulness of plant-based diets matters: diets rich in whole grains, fruits, and vegetables are linked to better long-term health, while those high in refined grains or sugars may be less beneficial, though short-term weight loss may still occur 11 13 14.
- Mediterranean diets also promote weight loss and cardiometabolic health, especially with energy restriction and increased physical activity, but may not result in as much weight loss as low-fat vegan diets in head-to-head trials 6 7 10.
Study Overview and Key Findings
Interest in the most effective dietary approaches for weight loss continues to grow, especially as plant-based and Mediterranean diets are both widely promoted for health. This new study investigates not only the comparative efficacy of a low-fat vegan versus Mediterranean diet for weight loss, but also explores the impact of including plant foods typically classified as “unhealthful” by existing diet indexes. The findings challenge common assumptions about the role of refined plant foods and oils in the context of vegan dietary patterns.
| Property | Value |
|---|---|
| Study Year | 2025 |
| Organization | Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine |
| Journal Name | Frontiers in Nutrition |
| Authors | Hana Kahleova, Reagan Smith, Ilana Fischer, Haley Brennan, Tatiana Znayenko-Miller, Richard Holubkov, Neal D. Barnard |
| Population | Adults with excess weight |
| Sample Size | 62 adults |
| Methods | Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) |
| Outcome | Weight loss, body composition, insulin sensitivity, cholesterol levels |
| Results | Vegan diet led to greater weight loss than Mediterranean diet. |
Literature Review: Related Studies
To situate this study within the broader scientific context, we searched the Consensus paper database (over 200 million research papers) using these queries:
- vegan diet weight loss comparison
- Mediterranean diet effectiveness weight loss
- plant-based diet health outcomes analysis
| Topic | Key Findings |
|---|---|
| How do vegan and vegetarian diets compare to other diets for weight loss? | - Vegan diets lead to greater weight loss than vegetarian, Mediterranean, and conventional diets in several randomized trials and meta-analyses 2 3 4 5. - Weight loss from vegan diets appears sustained at 1 and 2 years with support 3. |
| Does the healthfulness of plant-based foods affect weight loss and health outcomes? | - Diets higher in “healthy” plant foods (whole grains, vegetables, fruits) are linked to better weight loss and reduced risk of chronic disease; “unhealthy” plant-based foods (refined grains, sweets) may lessen these benefits 11 13 14. - Higher unhealthy plant-based diet scores are associated with higher coronary heart disease risk, while healthy plant-based diets are protective 11 13. |
| How does the Mediterranean diet perform for weight loss and metabolic health? | - Mediterranean diets promote modest weight loss, especially with energy restriction and increased physical activity, and improve glycemic and cardiovascular risk factors 6 7 8 9 10. - Compared to low-fat or other diets, Mediterranean diets produce similar or slightly less weight loss, but confer consistent cardiovascular benefits 6 8 10. |
| What is the impact of plant-based diets on long-term disease risk and mortality? | - Plant-based diets, especially those emphasizing healthy plant foods, are associated with lower risks of type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, cancer, and all-cause mortality; unhealthy plant-based diets do not confer these benefits 12 13 14 15. |
How do vegan and vegetarian diets compare to other diets for weight loss?
The new study's finding that a low-fat vegan diet results in greater weight loss than a Mediterranean diet is broadly consistent with previous randomized trials and meta-analyses. Across multiple studies, vegan diets have led to significantly greater reductions in body weight compared to vegetarian, pescatarian, semi-vegetarian, and omnivorous diets, even when calorie intake is not strictly limited 2 3 4.
- Vegan diets produced more weight loss at 6 months compared to omnivorous, semi-vegetarian, and pesco-vegetarian diets 2.
- A two-year trial found that a vegan diet led to more sustained weight loss than a moderate low-fat diet, with group support enhancing maintenance 3.
- Meta-analyses show vegetarian and especially vegan diets outperform non-vegetarian diets for weight reduction 4.
- Both vegan and Mediterranean diets are associated with improvements in metabolic outcomes, but the vegan approach may offer a greater reduction in weight for overweight individuals 2 3 4.
Does the healthfulness of plant-based foods affect weight loss and health outcomes?
A key nuance from observational and interventional research is that not all plant-based foods confer equal benefits. Diets rich in whole grains, fruits, vegetables, and nuts—classified as “healthful” plant foods—are consistently linked with better weight loss, lower cardiovascular risk, and reduced mortality. In contrast, diets high in refined grains, sweets, and sugar-sweetened beverages—labeled as “unhealthful” plant foods—may not provide these advantages and can even increase disease risk 11 13 14.
- Healthy plant-based diet indices (hPDI) are associated with reduced coronary heart disease and all-cause mortality, while unhealthy plant-based diet indices (uPDI) are linked to increased risk 11 13.
- Meta-analyses confirm that emphasizing healthy plant foods in plant-based diets strengthens the associations with reduced type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and cancer 14.
- The new study's finding—that weight loss occurred even with the inclusion of some “unhealthy” plant foods—suggests that the exclusion of animal products and reduction of oils/nuts may play a key role in short-term weight loss, but long-term health outcomes may depend more on plant food quality 11 14.
- Some observational studies suggest that unhealthy plant-based diets can increase risk of chronic diseases, highlighting the importance of plant food choices 11 13.
How does the Mediterranean diet perform for weight loss and metabolic health?
Mediterranean diets are widely recognized for their cardiovascular and metabolic benefits, particularly when paired with energy restriction and increased physical activity. In terms of weight loss, Mediterranean diets consistently outperform standard Western or low-fat diets, but may produce slightly less weight loss than vegan diets in some comparative studies 6 7 8 9 10.
- Randomized trials show that Mediterranean diets can lead to significant weight loss and improved metabolic outcomes, though the weight loss is generally modest unless calories are restricted 6 7 9 10.
- Compared to low-carbohydrate or vegan diets, the Mediterranean diet may result in similar or somewhat less weight loss, while still providing consistent improvements in glycemic control and cardiovascular risk factors 6 8 10.
- Meta-analyses find that Mediterranean diets do not lead to weight gain, even with higher fat intake, and can be a practical option for sustained weight management 7 10.
- In individuals with type 2 diabetes or metabolic syndrome, Mediterranean diets improve glycemic control, lipid profiles, and blood pressure 8 9.
What is the impact of plant-based diets on long-term disease risk and mortality?
Beyond weight loss, plant-based diets have been associated with lower risks of chronic diseases and premature mortality, particularly when the diet emphasizes whole, minimally processed plant foods. Unhealthy plant-based diets—those high in refined grains, sugars, and processed foods—do not appear to confer these benefits and may even be detrimental 12 13 14 15.
- Large cohort studies and meta-analyses show that healthy plant-based diets reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, cancer, and all-cause mortality 12 13 14.
- The protective effect is strongest when the diet emphasizes vegetables, fruits, whole grains, and legumes 14 15.
- Diets high in less healthy plant foods or low-quality carbohydrates are not associated with reduced disease risk and may increase risk 11 13 14.
- The new study's focus on short-term weight loss highlights that dietary composition (animal vs. plant foods, oils/nuts) may be more important for weight management in the short term, while long-term health outcomes depend on the quality of plant-based foods consumed 13 14 15.
Future Research Questions
While this study adds to the evidence that low-fat vegan diets can be effective for weight loss—even when including some less healthful plant foods—several important questions remain. Further research is needed to clarify the long-term clinical implications, mechanisms driving weight loss, and effects on diverse populations and health outcomes.
| Research Question | Relevance |
|---|---|
| What are the long-term health impacts of low-fat vegan diets that include unhealthful plant foods? | The current study focused on short-term weight loss. Long-term effects on cardiometabolic health, chronic disease risk, and mortality are not well known, especially when unhealthful plant foods are included 11 13 14. |
| How does the quality of plant-based foods affect weight loss and disease risk over time? | Observational studies suggest that healthy plant-based foods confer the most benefit, but the impact on sustained weight management and chronic disease prevention needs further investigation 11 13 14. |
| What mechanisms drive greater weight loss on vegan versus Mediterranean diets? | Identifying the physiological, metabolic, and behavioral factors that account for differential weight loss could enhance dietary interventions and personalization 2 3 4 6. |
| Do low-fat vegan diets maintain weight loss and health benefits beyond 1-2 years? | Most trials are relatively short; longer-term studies are needed to assess sustainability, adherence, and potential nutritional deficiencies or health concerns 3 4 10. |
| How do individual differences (e.g. genetics, metabolism, gut microbiome) influence response to vegan and Mediterranean diets? | Personal factors may affect diet efficacy, weight loss, and metabolic outcomes, but remain underexplored in comparative trials 6 8 14. |